Coaching or Therapy

Which one do you need?

Both can help when life gets hard. They overlap more than most comparisons acknowledge, but they are not the same. And what I do differs from what you'll usually find in either.

The overlap

More alike than the usual comparisons say

Simple splits like "therapy is about healing the past and coaching is about achieving a specific goal in the near future" sort of point in the right direction, but are a little too glib.

The reason therapy does a deep dive into the past is to free you up to achieve more in the future, and a good therapist will actively work with you on new thinking, feelings, behaviors, expectations, and accomplishments. They don't just wallow in the past for its own sake. Also, modern approaches to psychotherapy show a decreasing emphasis on the past, becoming increasingly focused on behavioral tactics, with or without insight.

Coaching doesn't focus on the past, but obviously occurs in the context your past experiences have established. An unusually good coach will actively work with you on seeing how your existing beliefs and assumptions (based on your past experience) are functioning as contemporary aids or obstacles, helping or hindering your pursuit of the future you hope to have.

What I do is neither as deeply probing as classical therapy nor as superficially naive as conventional coaching. I listen, especially for assumptions and beliefs that haven't been recognized as such. I disrupt them by offering a different way to interpret, or at least investigate, what's going on and how you perceive and respond to it. With the unsatisfying pattern loosened, I offer a way of seeing the situation that has room for a more satisfying relationship to what is happening – first more questions and then more clarity about what is really going on, more freedom and skills with which to adapt to it or change it.

When to see a therapist

  • You want a diagnosis, or treatment that may include medication, or to work with someone trained and licensed to go as deep as you need, wherever that leads

  • You are relying on alcohol, drugs, or some other compulsive or addictive behavior to get through the day, and it's getting worse

  • You are having symptoms that clearly demonstrate a high degree of trouble, such as recurring rage, loss of temper or self-control, wanting to leave a relationship but feeling stuck in it, hallucinations, or delusions

  • You are having thoughts of harming yourself. Please don't wait. In the US, call or text 988, and elsewhere, call your local emergency number.

When Zen-ish Coaching fits

  • A change, chosen or imposed, has left you unsure what comes next, at work, at home, in a relationship, or within yourself

  • You know something needs to change, and you aren't sure what, or in what way

  • You want to talk with someone who will speak supportively, yet still challenge your assumptions and blind spots, and offer you some new ways of seeing things and taking action

  • You want to talk in depth about something most conversations don't serve well

Why I might be a fit for you

Not a therapist, and not a typical coach

I am not a licensed therapist, and I am not a superficial accountability coach or a do-it-my-way coach. I am certified as a coach, which is frankly not a high bar, but I also have a B.A. in Psychology, an M.A. in Counseling Psychology, work experience in the field, and past licensure in psychiatric nursing. Sadly, a background in psychology is something nearly all coaches lack. My background not only informs our sessions, but is also why I can tell you if I think therapy is indicated. I also have a lot of vocational experience in the world of high-pressure employment (Silicon Valley high tech), and in the many roles and complexities of my own life. These give me many avenues into understanding your life. See my background here.

Free introductory call

Not sure which you need?

The introductory call is free, and it's a good place to find out. If therapy looks like the better fit, I'll say so.

Email Free intro call